‘The First Time the Old Corps was ever Whipped’: A Letter from Ream’s Station

This year we are remembering the 150th anniversary of the 1864 campaigns of the American Civil War. 1864 looms large in many of the pension files relating to Irishmen and their families that I have examined. That year, thousands of Northern Irishmen died both on battlefields and in Confederate prisons. For Irish-America, as for much of the American population, 1864 was a year of blood. The 25th of this month will mark the 150th anniversary of one of the most catastrophic days in what was already a costly year for Irish servicemen in the Army of the Potomac. It is a day which deserves significant attention from those of us interested in the Irish experience of the American Civil War.

The Second Battle of Ream's Station as depicted in Frank Leslie's Scenes and Portraits of the Civil War (Frank Leslie)

The Second Battle of Ream’s Station as depicted in Frank Leslie’s Scenes and Portraits of the Civil War (Frank Leslie)

The 25th August marks the anniversary of the Second Battle of Reams’ Station, when the Second Corps of the Army of the Potomac suffered its worst defeat of the war. Among the killed and captured were men from what had been the Irish Brigade, men from Corcoran’s Irish Legion, and men from other ‘ethnic’ Irish units. Large numbers of Irishmen were also present throughout the non-ethnic units of the Second Corps. Over the course of the coming weeks I hope to return to Ream’s Station on a number of occasions. The letter below was written by Second Lieutenant Dean Wilson of the 155th New York, Corcoran’s Irish Legion, on 28th August- three days after the battle. Addressed to the brother of the regiment’s Lieutenant-Colonel in Buffalo, it makes clear the scale of the disaster for his brigade:

Friend Mathew,

I now undertake the painful duty of informing you of the severe loss our Brigade met with on Thursday, 25th: that day the 1st and 2d Division of our Corps lay at Reams Station on the Weldon R.R.; about 5,500 muskets, the Division (Gibbon’s) being very small, and 12 pieces of artillery, with some Cavalry, under Gen. Gregg, Gen Hancock commanding the whole. Early in the morning our pickets were driven in at all points, and the rebel sharpshooters annoyed our batteries considerably; then commenced the fight in reality: we lay on the right angle of the 1st Division; they charged six times on our right and were repulsed with slaughter, but they brought up their batteries, I should say 20 or 25 pieces, and opened on us simultaneously; they were in such force they overlapped our lines in the right and let and came up in our rear; then commenced the slaughter. From front and rear they came swarming in with their yells, and seizing the artillery turned it immediately on our men; the Lieut. Col. was captured while endeavoring to get the men to stand by the guns. Capt. McConvey was wounded severely and carried about a mile, then the men that were carrying him had to leave him as the rebels were in our rear and right on top of us; he gave his money to the Adjutant of the 152d N.Y., who was captured with it afterwards, and Capt. McC., also, taken prisoner. Captains Doran. Pagee, Peluz, Quintz, Flynn, Hartford and Davis were captured. Lieut. Quinn was wounded in the arm and got off. We losr 41 men out of 75. CO. I lost James Clark, P. Donohugh and David Smith missing. J. Ryan and George Harry wounded, but got off the field. Co. K lost Sergt. McGowan, P. Kiennan, Amengo Bogert, James Cotter, P. Dolan, Louis Katrick missing; Sergt. Seymour was captured but got away again. The 164th has only one officer left- Capt. Burke. Thomas Cantwell was wounded and got off; the Brigade loss was 500 men; the 170th has one officer and about 30 men out of 150. We saved our Colors, so did the 69th and 170th; the 164th lost theirs; so did the 8th N.Y.H.A., who are in our Brigade. Prisoners taken told our officers that we were fighting Hill’s whole corps and two DIvisions of Beauregard’s Command, I hope and trust that my comrades and your friends will not be let rot in a Confederate prison; they captured from us 8 or 10 pieces of artillery and 1,700 prisoners.

Many of our troops would not leave the pits at all, preferring capture and imprisonment to running the chances of getting out from under the destructive artillery fire that was concentrated on us from all points front and rear, right and left. Gen. Hancock led a charge in person on the right, and Gen. Gibbon exposed himself fearlessly, but the day was gone against the noble 2d corps. Capt. Emblee, of Gen. Gibbons staff, led the 164th and the 8th N.Y.H.A., on the charge; but it was useless, as at that time the enemy were swinging in our rear; their artillery checked their rear from capturing more of us as they mowed down their own men with the artillery they captured and turned on us. I hope, dear friend, that I will never get in such another “tight place,” Gen. Gibbon cried; Hancock to-day and yesterday will let no one approach him; this is the first time the old corps was ever whipped; but the odds were three to one in artillery and men. I have tried to give you as true a statement as possible. Charley Priest is safe; also, the following men of Company I and K:- Sergeant P. Kelly, Sergeant Opping, — Seymour, John Donohue, William Heffernan, Allan Gray, James Griffin, John Monahan, Dan Frawley, and John Gallaher; we have four officers and thirty-eight men left. Please show this letter to Captain McNally, when you get through. Dr. Hasbrouck of the 164th, was ordered to take charge of the wounded when he comes back I may find something more definite in relation to the Lieutenant-Colonel and the men; if so, I will let you know at the earliest opportunity. Hoping you will have patience and take the brightest side of the picture,

I remain, your friend,

Dean Wilson,

2d Lieutenant, 155th N.Y.S.V. (1)

Shortly after receiving this letter the Irish-American also received a list of casualties among the brigade’s officers as follows:

One Hundred and Seventieth N.Y. Vols.- Major J.B. Donnelly, wounded and prisoner; Capt. James H. Keely, Capt. Turner, Adjt. Dunne, Lieuts. Quigley and Whelan, also wounded and prisoners. The command went into the fight some 70 strong, and lost more than half.

Sixty-Ninth, N.Y.S.M.- Capt. Welpley, killed; Lieut. D. Sweeney, killed; Capt. Canton and Lieut. O’Farrell, wounded; Lieut. E. Kelly, captured.

One Hundred and Fifty-Fifth N.Y. Vols- Major Byrne, Capts. Page, Doran, Pelouze and Lieut. O’Flynn, captured.

One Hundred and Sixty-Fourth, N.Y. Vols.- Major Beatty, Capts. Kelly, Hearne, O’Reilly and others, captured.  

The Legion now numbers about 200 men. (2)

Despite the slant that Lieutenant Wilson put on proceedings the Second Corps had not performed well at Ream’s Station. Consistently used as a strike arm during the course of the 1864 campaign, it was no longer the powerful formation it had once been. Battle fatigue and almost relentless casualties had taken their toll. Unfortunately the Lieutenant’s hope that the men would not be ‘left to rot’ in Confederate prisons did not come to fruition; many of those taken at Ream’s Station would never see their homes again.

(1) New York Irish-American 17th September 1864. (2) Ibid.


New York Irish-American 17th September 1864. War News.

Civil War Trust Second Battle of Ream’s Station Page


Tags: , , , , , , ,

Categories: 155th New York, Battle of Ream's Station, Corcoran's Irish Legion, New York

Author:Damian Shiels

I am an archaeologist based in Ireland, specialising in conflict archaeology.

Follow Irish in the American Civil War

Follow Irish in the American Civil War via Social Media

13 Comments on “‘The First Time the Old Corps was ever Whipped’: A Letter from Ream’s Station”

  1. August 3, 2014 at 6:34 pm #

    Great letter. Fascinating!

  2. August 5, 2014 at 5:33 pm #

    Great post! I was unfamiliar with this battle, but am glad to learn more about it. Thanks again:)

    • August 7, 2014 at 7:06 pm #

      Hi Mark,

      No problem glad you enjoyed it!

      Kind Regards,


  3. August 26, 2014 at 8:36 pm #

    The letter gives much insight to what was happening that day.Thanks, Damian.

  4. mickinlv
    September 27, 2014 at 7:36 am #

    Wow, what a find. In the end of the letter he lists a few men of the NY 155th co i that were safe. John Donohue is my great, great great uncle who was later promoted in jan.

    Also his brother Patrick Donohue (who is my great, great grandfather) also of the 155th co i was one of the captured that day actually escaped later on to rejoin the unit.

    • September 29, 2014 at 8:59 am #

      Hi Mick,

      Thanks for that information! Do you have much information about how they both got on afterwards? I am always interested in hearing about their post-war lives. Also do you know where they were born?

      Kind Regards,


  5. mickinlv
    September 27, 2014 at 9:32 pm #

    Great work though I’m not sure but do you have the original letter or working off one already transcribed? Because while I’m not 100% sure but the part where he writes ” We losr 41 men out of 75. CO. I lost James Clark, P. Donohugh and David Smith missing.”

    I believe the “P. Donohugh” actually Patrick Donohue. Who was 155th ny co i and captured on the 25th, and reported to have been sent to Libby

    • September 29, 2014 at 8:58 am #

      Hi Mick,

      Many thanks for the comment. The letter was reproduced in the New York Irish-American newspapers which is where this came from, so I have quoted directly from it. It was extremely common for them to mis-spell names in this period, both in the paper and on muster rolls- indeed the men themselves often had one or two variants! I would say that you are quite right that that P.Donohugh is Patrick Donohue and they are one and same man.

      Kind Regards,


  6. June 6, 2017 at 6:50 pm #

    Dean Wilson’s letter references my great grandfather, Patrick Donohue. He misspelled his last name, so I did not catch it the first time I read your article. Patrick was captured at Reams Station and spent 8 months in 4 prisons, 6 months in Salisbury, NC before escaping. He brought home with him a host of chronic diseases which he lived with for the rest of his life and which did not allow him to do heavy labor in a consistent fashion. His impact on his wife and children, especially his daughters, was very negative, as I detail in my book, HIMSELF, A CIVIL WAR VETERAN’S STRUGGLES WITH REBELS, BRITS, AND DEVILS. His weakened condition did not prevent him from participating in the most successful Fenian raid on Canada from Buffalo. Once again he was captured but through good luck spent no time in a Canadian jail.


  1. NP: September 17, 1864 Irish-American (NY): Corcoran Legion at Second Reams Station — The Siege of Petersburg Online - August 25, 2014

    […] Note: The majority of this article appeared on Damian Shiels’ Irish in the American Civil War Blog on August 3, 2014.  I have access to articles from the New York Irish American, so I decided to also post this […]

  2. ‘Our Pickets Were Gobbled’: Assessing the Mass Capture of the 69th New York, Petersburg, 1864 | Irish in the American Civil War - December 10, 2015

    […] without blots on their military record. In the East, engagements such as Ream’s Station (see here) and Second Deep Bottom were testament to the failing fighting strength of many such units. The […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: